Register for free to upload content and post comments

A user-driven online community and resource library for ethics teachers, scholars, and practitioners worldwide.

Teaching Ethics Through Clinical Self-Reflection

Submitted by JoNel Newman on Thu, 07-24-2014
Long title
Teaching Legal Ethics and Professionalism through Clinical Self-Reflection
Newman, JoNel, Swain, Melissa and Nicholson, Donald
Author(s)' contact information
University of Miami, USA
University of Strathclyde, UK
Conference title
International Legal Ethics Conference VI
Conference location
City University London
United Kingdom
Select the option that describes the rights you hold in the attached content
I have not attached any content.
Select a license for the attached content
I have not attached any content.
For some time now, ethical and professional educators have drawn on philosophy, psychology and educational theory to argue that one of, if not the most, effective means of teaching legal ethics is through immersion in and reflection on, ethical dilemmas arising out of real-life legal experiences in live-client law clinics. Unfortunately, empirical evidence supporting this theoretical position has thus far been elusive.
This panel will provide evidence of the alleged “clinic effect” drawn from the narratives of student journals and self-reflection memoranda that demonstrate longitudinally their progress towards identifying and resolving ethical issues and their development of professional values. The journal evidence comes from two very similar legal clinics: the University of Strathclyde Law School in Scotland and the University of Miami Law School in the United States. Both are designed to maximise the provision of direct legal representation to impoverished clients and hence have high case loads. Both also emphasise the learning of professional and ethical values and judgment through guided self-reflection in which students identify and reflect in writing on the moral, ethical and professional issues they have faced during their clinical experiences. At the same time, differences in the length of clinical experience between the two law clinics and the age of the students involved allow for an examination of whether these factors affect the impact of ethical development.
Other Topics